2023 Report

Sentiments: negotiations and pay

Negotiation is common but unevenly practised. Pay fairness perceptions are moderate, and most designers lack the resources to actively benchmark their own market value.

Published June 1, 2023 · Singapore, Malaysia, Indonesia, Philippines, Vietnam

Sentiments: negotiations and pay

Negotiation behaviour

57.1% of respondents negotiated their current compensation, 38.8% did not, and 4.1% said the question did not apply.

Chart proof

Negotiated current compensation

Whether respondents negotiated their current total compensation, among 317 answered responses.

View data table
ResponseRespondents (N=317)Share (%)
Yes 18157.1
No 12338.8
Not applicable 134.1

Men negotiate pay more often than women: 61% of men reported negotiating their last salary, compared to 51% of women, a 10-percentage-point gap. Whether that gap in who asks contributes to the fairness gap below is a question this survey cannot answer directly: the fairness ratings that follow are not broken down by gender.

Chart proof

Pay negotiation by gender

Share who negotiated their last salary, by gender (N=223, Singapore)

View data table
GenderNegotiated last salary
Men 61%
Women 51%

Compensation perceptions

Pay fairness for role and level averages 4.57 out of 7. More respondents lean towards agreement than disagreement: 57.1% rate their pay as fair for their role and level (ratings 5–7), against 24.6% who disagree (ratings 1–3), with the remainder sitting neutral.

Chart proof

Compensated fairly for role and level

1–7 Likert response distribution for the statement about role and level, where 1 - Strongly disagree and 7 - Strongly agree, among 317 answered responses.

View data table
ResponseRespondents (N=317)Share (%)
1 - Strongly disagree 144.4
2 - Disagree 3410.7
3 - Somewhat disagree 309.5
4 - Neutral 5818.3
5 - Somewhat agree 7222.7
6 - Agree 7724.3
7 - Strongly agree 3210.1

Market rate awareness

Designers' awareness of market rate sits slightly higher, averaging 4.71 out of 7, with 62.5% agreeing they know roughly where their pay sits relative to the market (ratings 5–7). That is a firmer consensus than for fairness itself.

Chart proof

Market rate awareness

1–7 Likert response distribution for the statement about market rate awareness, where 1 - Strongly disagree and 7 - Strongly agree, among 317 answered responses.

View data table
ResponseRespondents (N=317)Share (%)
1 - Strongly disagree 103.2
2 - Disagree 216.6
3 - Somewhat disagree 3410.7
4 - Neutral 5417.0
5 - Somewhat agree 9028.4
6 - Agree 8225.9
7 - Strongly agree 268.2

Staying informed on market rate

But access to resources for staying informed on market rate drops to 3.86 out of 7, the lowest sentiment score in this section. More respondents disagree (39.9%, ratings 1–3) than agree (36%, ratings 5–7) that they have good resources here. Designers broadly sense where they stand on pay; fewer have the tools to keep that sense current.

Chart proof

Staying informed on market rate

1–7 Likert response distribution for the statement about staying informed on market rate, where 1 - Strongly disagree and 7 - Strongly agree, among 316 answered responses.

View data table
ResponseRespondents (N=316)Share (%)
1 - Strongly disagree 227.0
2 - Disagree 4714.9
3 - Somewhat disagree 5718.0
4 - Neutral 7624.1
5 - Somewhat agree 6821.5
6 - Agree 3210.1
7 - Strongly agree 144.4

Negotiation confidence

Negotiation confidence averages 4.51 out of 7, with 52% agreeing they feel confident negotiating (ratings 5–7) against 29% who disagree (ratings 1–3).

Chart proof

Negotiation confidence

1–7 Likert response distribution for the statement about negotiation confidence, where 1 - Strongly disagree and 7 - Strongly agree, among 317 answered responses.

View data table
ResponseRespondents (N=317)Share (%)
1 - Strongly disagree 113.5
2 - Disagree 288.8
3 - Somewhat disagree 5316.7
4 - Neutral 6018.9
5 - Somewhat agree 5918.6
6 - Agree 7323.0
7 - Strongly agree 3310.4

More people negotiate than say they feel confident doing so.

Plenty negotiate anyway, discomfort and all.

Compensated fairly for effort

Compensated fairly for effort averages 4.58 out of 7, close to the 4.57 average for role and level. 55.1% agree they are paid fairly for their effort (ratings 5–7), against 25.6% who disagree (ratings 1–3), a similar split to the fairness-for-role question, suggesting the two perceptions move together.

Chart proof

Compensated fairly for effort

1–7 Likert response distribution for the statement about effort at work, where 1 - Strongly disagree and 7 - Strongly agree, among 316 answered responses.

View data table
ResponseRespondents (N=316)Share (%)
1 - Strongly disagree 113.5
2 - Disagree 3310.4
3 - Somewhat disagree 3711.7
4 - Neutral 6119.3
5 - Somewhat agree 6019.0
6 - Agree 8426.6
7 - Strongly agree 309.5

Sentiment findings reflect aggregate responses across 10 markets; 69.4% of respondents are Singapore-based.

Where this sits in the conversation

  1. Overview

    2023 report
  2. Landscape

    Demographics
  3. Landscape

    Roles and experience
  4. Landscape

    Compensation
  5. Landscape

    Company landscape
  6. Sentiments

    Sentiments: negotiations and pay you are here
  7. Sentiments

    Sentiments: work setup
  8. Sentiments

    Sentiments: career progression
  9. Singapore deep dive

    Analysis: gender 🇸🇬
  10. Singapore deep dive

    Analysis: experience 🇸🇬
  11. Singapore deep dive

    Analysis: company 🇸🇬
  12. Singapore deep dive

    Analysis: education 🇸🇬
  13. Close

    The first count